Prepared for Bill, Dustin & the Connelly teamWe inspected your website, Google Maps, reviews, speed, social and ads the same way you'd inspect a roof. Here's your score, what we found, three new homepages to pick from, and the plan to fix it.
Your 4.9★ rating, your license and insurance paperwork, and your real job photos are all strong. The problem is getting found: you're #23 on Google Maps for “roofing contractor Tacoma WA,” the address in your email signature is dead, your 100 reviews are split across three listings, and there's no Connelly video or Facebook page for homeowners to find.
On your Waller Rd Google listing (31 reviews). Your Portland Ave listing holds another 55 at 4.6★.
Google reviews across your listings. Plenty to build on once they're on one profile.
Owens Corning, CertainTeed, GAF, PABCO and IKO, plus IB Roofing for flat roofs. GAF's directory lists you at 4.6★.
Business certificate, license and insurance certificate posted for anyone to check. Most roofers don't.
Google's technical SEO score for your homepage, and 82 on desktop speed. The foundation is sound.
2026 job photos: drone shots, a TPO commercial roof, standing-seam metal. Exactly what a new homepage needs.
On Google Maps for “roofing contractor Tacoma WA,” your Waller Rd listing comes up 23rd (not counting ads). Homeowners rarely scroll past the first few. The companies on top all have hundreds of reviews on one listing. You have 100, split three ways, and two of those listings send people to a dead website.
Google Maps, “roofing contractor Tacoma WA,” November 20, 2026. Results vary by searcher and location.
Google's target for the main content to appear is 2.5 seconds. Most storm-season searches happen on phones, and people leave long before 12 seconds. The biggest drag is the image slider and code that blocks the page from drawing.
When a homeowner searches “roofer tacoma wa” and taps Short videos, Google fills the page with Facebook, Instagram and YouTube clips from local roofers. None are Connelly's. Nobody owns this spot yet, so the first roofer posting steadily gets it.
Google: the Ads Transparency Center shows 4 Google ads pointing to your website, all local Maps-style ads under Corehn's account. The one we opened was last shown August 31, 2026.
Facebook & Instagram: we couldn't find a Connelly Roofing Facebook page, and the Meta Ad Library shows no Connelly ads. Your website doesn't link to any social accounts. That's where neighbors ask “who did your roof?”, and where our video ads would run.
Fix connellyroofing.com Point it at your working site so email and Google clicks stop hitting an error.
1 dayClean up the three Google listings One main profile, one phone, one website, and every review working for it.
1–2 weeksQuick site repairs Take down the customer phone list, spam footer links and “driving schools” text; fix the logo and 0% offer.
1 dayLaunch the new homepage Pick A, B or C below. Fast on phones, with the instant estimate up top.
2–3 weeksFilm and post video Facebook, Instagram and YouTube set up and posting 3–4 videos a week.
WeeklyAsk every customer for a review Automatic text after each finished job, sent to your main listing.
OngoingThis is the first screen of connellyroofingandgutters.com on a laptop. Each red pin is something that costs you calls.
The logo in the top bar points to an old WP Engine address and doesn't load. The dark bar is empty where your name should be.
The first thing visitors read is a financing offer. If it isn't current, it's a promise you'd have to honor or explain. Your own brief flagged it too.
“CERTAINTEED · OWENS CORNING · PABCO” float over the photo, and a faint “Slider Revolution” watermark runs down the right edge.
It's a stock photo of a brick-and-stucco home that doesn't look like Pierce County. You have great real job photos already on the site.
Only “Email Us” and a phone number. Today's homeowners want a number first. Your BidDrop estimator is ready but not on the site.
Shingle brand pages and color pages fill the menu. Commercial roofing lives at a page called “/testimonials-2/”.
Your email signatures (Bill's and the office's) and two of the Google listings link to connellyroofing.com. When we opened it on November 20, it showed a Cloudflare “DNS resolution error.” Every customer who clicks your website from an email or one of those Google listings hits a dead page. It's usually a quick DNS fix: point it to your working site.
| Item | What we found | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| connellyroofing.com | Shows a Cloudflare DNS error. It's the address in your email signatures and on two Google listings. | Replace |
| Google listings | Three Google Maps listings named Connelly Roofing & Gutters: 4.6★ (55 reviews, Portland Ave E), 4.9★ (31, Waller Rd E) and 4.4★ (14, S Adams St). Only the Waller Rd listing links to your working site. Splitting 100 reviews three ways weakens all of them. (Please confirm which are yours.) | Repair |
| Google search text | Every page's description (the gray text under your link on Google) reads “BeDriving | Best WordPress theme for Driving schools.” | Quick win |
| Page titles & headline | The main headline is “Roofing Company Tacoma WA - Free Estimate CONNERG819QF.” Every page title ends in “Roofing Company Tacoma Seattle.” No town pages for Puyallup, Lakewood, Federal Way, etc. | Repair |
| First screen | Stock photo, unconfirmed 0% offer, slider leftovers, broken header logo. | Replace |
| Getting a price | Contact form with reCAPTCHA and a phone number. No instant estimate. | Replace |
| Customer privacy | The Testimonials page lists 10 past customers by name with their personal phone numbers, open to anyone (and to spam callers). | Quick win |
| Reviews on the site | The same two testimonials repeat three times on the homepage. None of your 100 Google reviews appear. | Repair |
| Footer links | “We like:” links out to two car-accident lawyers and unrelated companies. Google treats these as paid/spam links. | Quick win |
| Mixed claims | Homepage says “30+ years” and “over 20 years.” Site says BBB A-; your BBB profile showed A+ when your team checked in October. | Quick win |
| Broken pages & typos | TPO and metal project pages return “not found.” Typos like “gutter installtion” and “We have helped of home owners.” 6 of 20 homepage images have no alt text. | Quick win |
| Tracking | Google tag and Google Ads remarketing are installed. No Meta (Facebook) pixel, so Facebook/Instagram ads can't retarget site visitors. | Repair |
| Blog | 3 posts (roof cost in Tacoma, materials for Western WA rain, TPO vs torch down). Good topics, too few. | Repair |
| Social media | The website has no links to Facebook, Instagram or YouTube, and we couldn't find active Connelly pages from it. No video anywhere. Fix: claim/clean up pages, link them, post 3–4 videos a week. | Replace |
| Real job photos | Strong 2026 photos in your project gallery: drone shots, a TPO commercial roof, a standing-seam metal roof. | Keep |
| Credentials | License #CONNERG819QF, business certificate, insurance certificate, BBB seal and Hearth financing are all posted. | Keep |
Inspection done November 20, 2026 on connellyroofingandgutters.com, connellyroofing.com and Google Maps. Review counts change daily.
Each one is a full, working homepage with your logo, your photos, your license and your real reviews. Click any preview to open it full screen, then scroll and tap around.
Clean, bright and trusted. Your drone photo up top with an instant-estimate box right in the first screen, a trust bar, and a FAQ.
Dark, loud and confident. Huge type, your crew and video front and center, and a wall of every service you offer.
Calm and editorial. Serif headlines, big photos, a numbered service list and a town index. Built to win larger homes and commercial work.
Our crew films on your jobs, back-to-back days, then turns it into long videos for your website and YouTube plus short clips for Facebook, Instagram and ads. Real samples from contractors we work with:
Every piece hands the homeowner to the next one, and nothing falls through the cracks.
Screenshots from our own clients' Google, Facebook, YouTube and social dashboards. Two home-service contractors in Southeast Michigan: Custom Deck Creations (decks) and Seal Tech Insulation (spray foam). Tap any screenshot to enlarge it.
When a homeowner searches “deck installer near me” and taps Short videos, Custom Deck owns the page.
For “roofer tacoma wa,” Connelly shows up in 0 of 24. That's the spot we'd go after first.
The top ad isn't a polished commercial. It's the owner and a crew lead talking on a job. A Connelly re-roof filmed the same way becomes your best ad.
Over 90 days: 264 leads at $11.95 each.
Each one answers a question homeowners actually ask, for a named list of towns. For Connelly: “Is moss ruining your roof?”, “Repair or replace after a wet winter?” and “TPO vs torch down for flat roofs.”
Calls, website clicks and direction requests from Seal Tech's Google profile, May – October 2026.
Times their profile showed up for the plain search “insulation,” not their name.
Across 270 Google reviews, nearly triple your combined count today.
“It paid for itself in the first week.” Jack, Seal Tech's owner, says they closed multiple $8,000–$15,000 jobs from the new leads.
Full case study: americashomeexperts.us/results · Client dashboards are screenshots supplied by our clients; views and impressions are reach, not leads. No guarantee of the same results.
If it isn't working, you give 30 days' notice and keep everything we made: the website, the videos and the content.
Call-tracking phone number usage is billed separately, based on usage. Card payments include a 3.5% processing fee; ACH has no fee.
We're booking December and January filming trips now. Pick a time and we'll walk through your favorite homepage together.
Book a 20-minute callor call/text John Bujak · (734) 657-3141 · john@americashomeexperts.com
All checks done November 20, 2026. Speed: Google PageSpeed Insights, connellyroofingandgutters.com (mobile 62, LCP 12.8 s, render-blocking savings 1.6 s; desktop 82; SEO 100). Maps: Google Maps search “roofing contractor Tacoma WA,” organic position and review counts. Video: Google search “roofer tacoma wa,” Short videos tab, first 24 results. Ads: Google Ads Transparency Center (domain connellyroofingandgutters.com) and Meta Ad Library (“Connelly Roofing”). Social: links on your website and a Facebook page search. Site: page titles, descriptions, images and links on connellyroofingandgutters.com; connellyroofing.com returned a Cloudflare DNS error. Category scores other than mobile speed are our assessment from these measurements. Proof screenshots: client-supplied dashboards with the dates shown.